Vlahovic or Shesko? Manchester United’s striker dilemma for the 2025 season
Introduction: Manchester United’s striker search
Manchester United are entering the 2025-26 season with a serious problem: the lack of a skilled striker to lead their attacking line. Their weaknesses in front of goal were exposed last season, as Rasmus Hojlund’s form remained shaky and backup options failed to materialise. With the departure of Anthony Martial and Marcus Rashford’s poor performances, the Red Devils are now actively looking for a new, reliable option.
Two names are prominent in this discussion: RB Leipzig’s rising star Benjamin Shesko and Juventus’ powerful Serbian forward Dusan Vlahovic. However, while United are pushing hard for Shesko, Juventus have reportedly offered Vlahovic to the Premier League giants. This has created an interesting dilemma: should United spend more on their potential or acquire a proven striker on the cheap?
1: Why United need a new striker
Ultimately, the 2024–25 season saw Manchester United fall out of the top four while facing significant goal-scoring issues.
Moreover, their expected goals (xG) numbers were average for a team of their caliber, and they relied heavily on midfielders like Bruno Fernandes to create goal-scoring opportunities.
Key issues:
For example, Rasmus Højlund’s lack of consistency was evident—he managed just 4 league goals in 32 games.
Additionally, there was no backup firepower—Martial was injured, and Rashford was often deployed on the wing.
Therefore, a potent striker is essential if United hopes to return to the Champions League and compete at the highest level in Europe.
This is why Erik ten Hag and the board have prioritized signing a forward before the transfer window closes.
2: The Case of Benjamin Shesko
Among Europe’s rising stars, 22-year-old Benjamin Šeško is widely regarded as a top striker prospect.
Currently with RB Leipzig, he consistently performed well, scoring 18 goals in all competitions last season.
Strengths:
Height and physique (6’4″)
Great movement without the ball
Composure in front of goal
Potential to be world-class
Why United wants him:
Long-term investment
Fits into Ten Hag’s high-pressing system
Can be moulded into a complete forward
Transfer details:
Despite interest from several clubs, Leipzig remain adamant about a €70–80 million fee, plus add-ons.
Newcastle have also made a record bid of around €80 million.
Meanwhile, Šeško is weighing proposals from both United and Newcastle, with reports suggesting he favors the Red Devils.
If United acquire him, Shesco could become the cornerstone of their attack for the next decade.
3: Newcastle United complicate the picture
However, Newcastle United’s interest has complicated Manchester United’s transfer plans.
The Magpies have made a club-record bid and are looking for guaranteed play as well as European play New Zealand are offering Dusan Vlahovic time to compete.
Newcastle’s offer:
Competitive salary package
Key player role
Champions League football
United, on the other hand, offer:
Big global stage
Premier League legacy
Ten Hag’s track record with youngsters
At this point, the decision reportedly lies in Šeško’s hands—and time is running out.
4: Vlahovic’s turning point
While United were after Shesco, Juventus offered Dusan Vlahovic to the Red Devils. After his break-up with Fiorentina, the Serbian striker was once one of the most coveted players in Europe, but his time at Juventus has been full of ups and downs.
What we know:
According to sources, Juventus are seeking €30–35 million to part ways with Vlahović.
As a result, the club needs to generate funds to facilitate additional transfers.
Vlahović is Premier League-ready and open to a transfer.
United reportedly initially turned down the offer, but should they reconsider?
5: What Vlahovic offers
Vlahovic, 25, is a physically imposing striker with the ability to score goals.
Strengths:
- Clinical finisher
- Strong in aerial duels
- Proven in Serie A
- Still young but experienced
Concerns:
- Inconsistent form at Juventus
- Injury worries
- Reported attitude problems
Despite the risks, he remains a fine striker when fit and focused.
6. Financial comparison
| Category | Benjamin Šeško | Dusan Vlahović |
|---|---|---|
| Age | 22 | 25 |
| Club | RB Leipzig | Juventus |
| Estimated Fee | €80M + €10M add-ons | €30–35M |
| Market Value | €65M | €45M |
| Salary | Moderate | High |
Insight:
Undoubtedly, Vlahović presents the more budget-friendly short-term solution for United.
However, Šeško’s higher price reflects his long-term potential and current form.
The decision comes down to whether United prioritizes experience or future value.
7. What the experts are saying
Many experts are unanimous:
Louis Saha: “United should take Vlahovic now. He’s experienced and hungry.”
Jamie Carragher: “Chesco has the edge in terms of long-term upside.”
Fabrizio Romano: “United will remain focused on Shesco. Vlahovic is an option.”
The fan base is also divided. Some want a big-name proven scorer, while others prefer a younger player.
8. Tactical synergy
Shesco under Ten Hag:
- Excellent in transitions
- Good link-up play
- Can thrive in a fast system
Vlahovic under Ten Hag:
- More goal-marking
- Will change the team’s playing style
- Less apt to press
If Ten Hag wants continuity in his philosophy, Shesco seems the better option.
9. Making a tactical decision
Manchester United have a big decision to make. They need to consider:
- Short-term needs (Vlahovic)
- Long-term outlook (Shesko)
- Financial implications
- Team balance
- Ideal scenario:
- Establish Shesko as top option
If Shesko chooses Newcastle, bet on Vlahovic
But there is a risk: if they wait too long, both could leave.
10. Conclusion – Who should United choose?
This is more than a transfer—it’s a statement of identity. Stats and price are secondary.
If Manchester United want a ready scorer who can hit the ground running, then Dusan Vlahovic is perfect.
But if they believe in building a team for the future, then Benjamin Shesko is a great option.
With time running out, the stage is set at Old Trafford. Will the future belong to Vlahović’s raw power or Šeško’s rising stardom?
Stay tuned. The story has just begun.
