Week 1 highlights for Week 2025 NFL preseason: breakouts, surprises and disappointments for new players
Introduction
The 2025 NFL preseason kicked off with a first week that delivered everything a football fan could want—new player debuts, tremendous plays and some unexpected failures.
For many young players, it was their first taste of NFL action, a chance to prove they could belong under the bright lights. From Shedeur Sanders’ balanced pass rush to Ashton Jeanty’s tough start, Week 1 was filled with many storylines that could shape the regular season ahead.
Here’s a breakdown of the great performances, defensive dominance, special teams performances and some of the shortcomings of Week 1.
1. Shedre Sanders shines in Browns debut
New quarterback Shedre Sanders wasted no time making his mark, completing 14 of 23 passes for 138 yards and two touchdowns. Sanders showed composure and accuracy beyond his age. He led several scoring drives before fouling out in the third quarter with Cleveland in firm control. Browns fans have every reason to be excited about the future of their new quarterback.
2. Tanner Mackey proves value as backup for Eagles
With Jalen Hurts sitting out, Tanner Mackey stole the spotlight. He completed 20 of 25 passes for 252 yards, scored two touchdowns and a rushing score. His decision-making and ball placement were sharp, solidifying his role as a starting backup. Philadelphia’s quarterback depth looks strong this season.
3. Lajounte Wester energizes the Ravens’ special teams
New wide receiver Lajounte Wester stole the show with a punt return touchdown and several explosive plays. His speed and field vision make him a great player on special teams—and potentially a playmaker on offense, too.
4. Mike Green shows pass-rush ability
The Ravens also got a boost from new wide receiver Mike Green, who consistently won his matchups off the edge. His lightning speed off the snap and ability to collapse the pocket could earn him rotational snaps early in the season.
5. Jay Higgins IV makes his case
An undrafted freshman linebacker, Jay Higgins IV, made the most of his preseason debut with an interception and a crucial pass breakup. Performances like these keep coaches on the watch during roster cuts.
6. Tyler Loop responds under pressure
New kicker Tyler Loop didn’t get off to a good start, missing the initial field goal, but he came back with a great 52-yard conversion. That’s the resilience special teams coaches like to see in a young kicker.
7. Ashton Jeanty’s memorable debut
Running back Ashton Jeanty, the Raiders’ sixth overall pick, had a memorable debut—just three carries for 1 yard. While there’s no need to panic just yet, expectations were high after his dominance in college, leading to a disappointing start.
8. Falcons defense off to a rocky start
Even without their star defensive backs, the Falcons defense performed well early on. On the very first drive against Detroit, they forced turnovers with consistent pass rushes and aggressive tackling. It’s a start that builds defensive confidence.
Conclusion
The first week of the 2025 NFL preseason reminded fans just how important August football is. It’s more than just a warm-up—it’s a testing ground for rookies, backup players and players fighting to make the roster. From Sanders and McKie’s explosive performances under center to Wester’s special teams magic and the Falcons’ defensive prowess, Week 1 laid the groundwork for an exciting preseason.
If these performances are any indication, the regular season could be full of breakout stars and surprising contributors.